The following is an illustrative example written to show how an assessment works. It is not a real Evelon Digital client, not a historical case, and not a stated result.
The situation. A small bar on Lonsdale Street receives a one-star review describing a $22 cocktail the bar has never listed, posted from a profile whose only other review is a five-star rating of a bar two doors down.
What gets checked. The bar's current and past drinks menu and pricing for the period described, and the reviewer profile's posting history and account creation date.
How it would be assessed. A menu item and price that never existed supports either a wrong-venue argument or a fake-engagement one, depending on what the wording actually describes. The profile's narrow, competitor-adjacent posting pattern is a secondary factor rather than proof on its own.
What we would not tell you. That the review will definitely come down, or on what date. Google decides every report independently, and a well-evidenced one can still be refused.